Meet Withbert W. Payne, CPA  |  Request a Complimentary Review
Call  (925) 708-6501
For a Complimentary Review

Understanding Long-Term Care

Fact vs. Fiction About Long-Term Care

The eight misconceptions that most often derail long-term care planning — and what the evidence actually shows.

Each pair presents the myth as it is typically heard, followed by the evidence-based response.

Myth 1 of 8

Medicare Will Cover My Long-Term Care Costs

✗  Fiction

Medicare covers long-term care, so I don’t need separate insurance.

This is the most widespread misconception in retirement planning.

✓  Fact

Medicare covers acute care. Custodial long-term care is excluded.

Medicare pays for hospitalization, surgery, physician visits, and short-term skilled nursing following a qualifying hospital stay — up to 100 days, with significant co-pays after day 20. It generally does not cover ongoing home health aides for custodial care, assisted living, memory care, or adult day programs. Those are the services most extended care events actually require.

Myth 2 of 8

My Family Will Take Care of Me

✗  Fiction

My spouse or children will provide care at home. I don’t need a policy.

Most families believe this until the care event begins.

✓  Fact

Family caregiving has financial, physical, and emotional limits.

Professional memory care in the Bay Area commonly runs $150,000 or more per year. Few family caregivers can sustain full-time employment while providing meaningful daily care, and the physical and emotional toll is well documented. Long-term care coverage does not remove the family from the picture — it funds professional care so that family members remain family members rather than unpaid caregivers.

Myth 3 of 8

I’ll Self-Insure — I Have Enough Assets

✗  Fiction

I have significant savings. I’ll simply pay for care out of pocket if I need it.

Self-insurance is rational for low-probability events with defined costs. Extended care is neither.

✓  Fact

Self-insuring a 70% probability, multi-year, seven-figure exposure is a high-risk strategy.

At Bay Area rates of roughly $15,000 a month for one person, three years of care is about $540,000 and a ten-year dementia event — not unusual with advanced Alzheimer’s — approaches $1.8 million. If both spouses need care, the ten-year figure approaches $3.6 million. For most families, self-insuring means liquidating retirement assets in exactly the years a surviving spouse depends on them. Many hybrid designs also include a return-of-premium feature if care is never needed, subject to policy terms and vesting schedules.

Myth 4 of 8

I’m Too Young to Think About This

✗  Fiction

Long-term care planning is best addressed closer to retirement.

Many professionals delay because the risk feels distant. The underwriting window does not wait.

✓  Fact

The underwriting window closes well before most people expect.

The best window for coverage — broadest carrier selection, lowest premiums, widest benefit options — is typically the late fifties and early sixties. Roughly half of applicants over age 70 are declined. The health conditions that disqualify applicants usually develop in the sixties, well before care is needed. For partners at the Big 4, the planning window is often narrowest in the final years before mandatory retirement — while income is high, health is favorable, and underwriting options remain open. Once the window closes, it does not reopen.

Myth 5 of 8

Long-Term Care Insurance Is Too Expensive

✗  Fiction

Premiums are prohibitively expensive and may increase unpredictably.

Traditional standalone policies have seen premium increases. Hybrid designs are structurally different.

✓  Fact

Modern hybrid policies carry premiums that are guaranteed not to increase — and retain value if care is never needed.

Hybrid long-term care policies built on a life insurance chassis carry level premiums, often a single lump-sum deposit, that are guaranteed not to increase. If care is never needed, a meaningful death benefit passes to beneficiaries. For a California C-corporation owner, the estimated net capital exposure — premium less cash value, less the corporate tax benefit on the qualified long-term care portion — can be roughly $70,000 in one age-50 couple illustration, with a death benefit of $300,000 or more retained. Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances; see the Tax Advantages page and consult your CPA.

Myth 6 of 8

Long-Term Care Mostly Means a Nursing Home

✗  Fiction

If I need long-term care I’ll end up in a nursing home, and I’d rather not plan for that.

The nursing home assumption causes many people to dismiss the conversation entirely.

✓  Fact

Most claims involve care delivered outside a nursing home.

Connecticut Partnership claims data covering 6,878 claimants shows home health aide services in 53% of claims and assisted living in 29%; nursing home care accounts for 27%. Because a claimant may receive care in more than one setting over the life of a claim, these percentages total more than 100%. The planning point is unchanged: a well-designed policy funds care in whatever setting the individual prefers, and for most claimants that setting is home.

Myth 7 of 8

The Government Will Cover It Through Medi-Cal

✗  Fiction

If I run out of money, Medi-Cal will pay for my care.

Medi-Cal is a safety net of last resort, not a planning strategy.

✓  Fact

Medi-Cal covers long-term care only after assets have been spent down to eligibility levels.

Medi-Cal does pay for long-term care, but only once personal assets have been depleted to program thresholds. For a professional with retirement savings, a home, and a spouse who depends on those assets, Medi-Cal spend-down means dismantling everything the retirement plan was built to protect. California’s Long-Term Care Partnership Program historically allowed policyholders to shelter assets dollar for dollar against Medi-Cal eligibility; according to the California Department of Health Care Services, no Partnership-approved insurers are currently issuing new Partnership policies, so it is best treated as historical context rather than a current planning option.

Myth 8 of 8

If I Don’t Use It, I Lose It

✗  Fiction

Premiums are wasted if I never make a claim.

A legitimate concern for traditional standalone policies. It does not apply the same way to hybrid structures.

✓  Fact

Hybrid policies are designed so that premiums are not simply lost.

A hybrid policy links long-term care coverage to a life insurance or annuity chassis. If care is never needed, beneficiaries receive a meaningful death benefit. In some designs a surrender value remains accessible during the policyholder’s lifetime, subject to policy terms; surrender values may be less than premiums paid in the early years. The result is a policy that functions both as extended care protection and as a legacy asset.

Long-Term Care by the Numbers

70%

Will Need Extended Care After Age 65

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Not a marginal risk — the actuarial expectation for the majority.

53%

Of Claims Involve Home Health Aide Care

Connecticut Partnership claims data. Coverage funds care at home, not only in facilities.

~50%

Of Applicants Over 70 Are Declined

The underwriting window narrows sharply with age. Waiting is the highest-risk strategy of all.

$540K

Three Years of Care at Bay Area Rates

Roughly $15,000 a month for one person. A ten-year dementia event approaches $1.8 million.

“Long-term care planning isn’t about predicting the future. It’s about protecting your independence, preserving your assets, and giving your family choices when they matter most.”

— Withbert (Bert) W. Payne, CPA, CGMA, FCA

Every long-term care plan should answer three questions.

  • Who will provide the care?
  • Where will the care be delivered?
  • Who will pay for it?

The earlier those questions are answered, the more options — and the more peace of mind — you are likely to have.

Request Your Personalized Illustration

No cost. No obligation.

An independent, carrier-neutral analysis of your long-term care options, prepared and reviewed personally by Bert Payne, CPA.

Withbert (Bert) W. Payne, CPA, CGMA, FCA · (925) 708-6501

3150 Crow Canyon Place, Suite 100, San Ramon, CA 94583

For educational purposes only. Not financial, legal, tax, or insurance advice. Coverage is subject to medical underwriting and policy availability. Benefit and premium figures are drawn from sample illustrations and will vary by age, health, carrier, and benefit design. Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances; consult your CPA.